What to do if you suspect medical malpractice.
Med-mal cases live or die on records. Here is how to get them, what to preserve, and who to involve — without tipping off the provider's risk-management team prematurely.
Get your records first
Under HIPAA, you have a right to a copy of your records within 30 days of a written request (45 C.F.R. § 164.524). Request everything: physician progress notes, nursing notes, imaging studies on disc (not just reports), pathology slides if cancer-related, medication administration record (MAR), and the EHR audit trail. The audit trail shows who accessed the chart and when — often revealing late edits or after-the-fact additions.
Document contemporaneously
- Symptoms by date and time.
- Every conversation with providers — who said what, when.
- Family members who witnessed conversations or care.
- Photos of visible injuries (surgical sites, bedsores, IV infiltrates).
- Receipts for out-of-pocket expenses and mileage to follow-up appointments.
Get a second opinion
Before consulting a lawyer, get a fresh treating-physician evaluation from an unrelated provider. The second-opinion note is medical evidence; it has independent value beyond what an expert later opines. Do not tell the second-opinion provider you are considering litigation; you want their clinical assessment, not their cautious-of-suit version.
Consult a med-mal lawyer before risk management
Hospital risk-management teams contact patients early to gather information that is admissible against them later. Decline recorded statements. Direct all communication to your lawyer once retained. Most med-mal lawyers screen cases on contingency at no upfront cost.
Mind the deadlines
The statute of limitations can be as short as 1 year (Louisiana, Kentucky). The statute of repose can bar claims even within the limitations window. See the dedicated med-mal statute of limitations guide for your state.
What not to do
- Do not give a recorded statement to risk management.
- Do not sign a release or write off a bill.
- Do not post about the care on social media.
- Do not assume an apology means you have a case — or that no apology means you don't.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- [1]HIPAA Privacy Rule — Right of Access to Medical Records — U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- [2]Apology Statutes — state survey — National Conference of State Legislatures
- [3]Patient Safety and Quality Improvement — Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality